I applaud the philanthropic - the carrying out of activities for the common and wider good rather than selfishly, be they in an investment of time, money or influence. We're (as a family) very lucky in what we have, and I would like to think that some of the things we do and spend on aren't purely selfish - i.e. to make us even luckier.
However - I abhore being approached by charity collectors in person, or by phone calls to us (as a business) from professional beggars who seem to be under the impression that it's alright to chase people at work far more strongly than people at home, and that an answer of "no" doesn't really mean that - it means "try again later - you may reach someone else who is more badgerable".
Visiting an ATM in Melksham last autumn, I was acosted by an old boy shaking his charity tin at me. He was very earnest in putting his cause, and it's one that has huge national support. But, alas, I really didn't want to stop at that point and give money to a charity I had contributed to just a few hours earlier via another collection, nor did I want him so close that he could read my PIN number as I was entering it.
The newspaper this morning headlines "War declared on Street Chuggers" and it states:
• Barred from within 3 metres of shop doorways, station entrances, crossings and cashpoints
• Ability to approach working public curbed
• Ban on pursuing people for more than three steps
Excellent ... except that I think these rules may apply only to people who are looking to get you to sign direct debit mandates. They should - in my view - apply to any charitable collection, whether looking for single or multiple payment.
Not only are collector's fees questionable, but a street approach doesn't give the potential donor an opportunity to think through the donation - to ask things like:
• Do I really want to support this cause?
• How much of my contribution actually gets to the headlined cause, and how much is commission and admin?
• Am I / should I be already supporting this cause through my taxes?
• Is there another cause I would prefer to support?
I have no objection to the handing out of leaflets on the street (but make the leafletting organisation responsible for clearing up any that are discarded). And - by all means - include web sites, SMS phone numbers and other ways to contribute on them.
"We're not exactly the most popular people" one chugger (charity mugger) is quoted as saying ... what a travesty that such people are praying on the goodwill of people and how much better it would be to restore faith in charity.
(written 2012-08-21, updated 2012-11-04)
Associated topics are indexed as below, or enter http://melksh.am/nnnn for individual articles
Z300 - Politics and Religion [216] Cheap purchase - votes paid for with selfish promises - (2005-02-15)
[257] Politics gets nasty. Must be an election coming up. - (2005-03-25)
[280] Spotted - the local MP - (2005-04-15)
[289] MP for Devizes, Wiltshire - (2005-04-23)
[301] General Election day, UK - (2005-05-05)
[313] Making bona fide international marriages more difficult - (2005-05-16)
[326] UK Tax payment totals and where the money is spent - (2005-05-27)
[335] Sad priorities - (2005-06-03)
[377] A Strengthened City - (2005-07-14)
[384] Managing conflict and disappointment - (2005-07-20)
[415] Campaign Drift and efficiency. - (2005-08-15)
[469] Yesterday was Kiss and Ride - (2005-10-19)
[505] Would you steal ... petrol? ... a training course? - (2005-11-26)
[539] rich and famous - (2005-12-23)
[602] MP face to face - (2006-02-12)
[607] On being British - (2006-02-14)
[671] Both ends of the animal - (2006-04-05)
[674] Wiltshire to get an extra MP - (2006-04-07)
[682] Iran has enriched uranium ... - (2006-04-12)
[696] Is than an uphill or downhill task? - (2006-04-23)
[750] Almost everyone loses - (2006-06-07)
[780] Separation and Integration - (2006-06-27)
[875] Wilfred Emmanuel-Jones - (2006-09-22)
[967] Realistic on line shoot'em up - (2006-12-05)
[1003] Room at the Inn, Guy at the station - (2006-12-21)
[1060] What a relief from the tax office. - (2007-02-01)
[1109] False imprisonment - a contrast from the news - (2007-03-15)
[1135] Government pressure on me to shut up after I make the papers - (2007-04-05)
[1175] Local elections - choosing who to vote for - (2007-05-03)
[1247] An afternoon at a public enquiry - (2007-06-27)
[1260] An inspirational business talk from one of our prospective MPs - (2007-07-06)
[1350] FSB (Federation of Small Businesses) Western Region - (2007-09-13)
[1386] New software product for warmblooded programmers - (2007-10-10)
[1428] Travel Across Wiltshire - the game - (2007-11-11)
[1526] Carers at work - court case changes - (2008-02-01)
[1573] Budget tax increases hit vehicle market - (2008-03-14)
[1579] Rome, and the faith of Rome - (2008-03-17)
[1729] Back from the future - (2008-07-30)
[1769] July child ponders on August children - (2008-08-23)
[1872] Barack Obama wins US Predidency - (2008-11-05)
[1881] Wiltshire Council says - part 1 - (2008-11-13)
[1882] Wiltshire Council says - part 2 - (2008-11-14)
[1987] One Cheer for Local Democracy - Asda in Melksham - (2009-01-11)
[2012] The Wiltshire Police - (2009-01-29)
[2028] Things people say on the phone - (2009-02-06)
[2075] Supporting Parkinsons and Trains - (2009-03-11)
[2178] Melksham Candidates for Wiltshire Unitary Election - (2009-05-12)
[2206] Spot the odd one out - (2009-05-29)
[2257] Ramblings on church and state linkage in Melksham - (2009-06-25)
[2270] Wiltshire - a chance to improve life for everybody - (2009-07-05)
[2279] Understanding the new local government structure in Wiltshire - (2009-07-11)
[2288] Wiltshire Community Area Partnerships - (2009-07-15)
[2353] All change - Wiltshire Parliamentary - (2009-08-13)
[2640] How is your tax pound spent? - (2010-02-18)
[2689] Can my dog eat potatoes? Doggie Dietary Research, and political sleaze! - (2010-03-23)
[2712] A more informed decision than ever before - (2010-04-08)
[2740] Melksham Hustings at George Ward School - (2010-04-26)
[2752] Voting day - UK General Election - (2010-05-06)
[2757] Bodicea, Lincoln, and our new MP - (2010-05-09)
[2792] Should Government compete with private industry? - (2010-06-03)
[2824] A pint of Black Rat, and a lazy barman - (2010-06-25)
[2856] Two sides of the coin - (2010-07-06)
[2864] Changing with weather and seasons - (2010-07-10)
[2870] Old prices - what would the equivalent price have been in 1966? - (2010-07-14)
[2948] Melksham shamefully makes the national headlines - (2010-09-07)
[2971] Should the public sector compete with businesses? and other deep questions - (2010-09-26)
[3051] Positively reforming the system - could it be done? - (2010-11-14)
[3264] Alternative Vote (AV) - explaining and an example - (2011-04-25)
[3313] What does our MP do on a Bank Holiday? - (2011-05-30)
[3323] Is Melksham town centre dying? - (2011-06-11)
[3325] The Olympic Torch, and Melksham House - (2011-06-14)
[3438] Melksham to become a part of Trowbridge? - (2011-09-13)
[3592] Are we one man, one vote? No, and we never have been. - (2012-01-26)
[3676] Rising prices, changing habits and society - (2012-03-31)
[3806] 2011 Census results - initial figures for Wiltshire. - (2012-07-17)
[3905] How should we choose our Wiltshire Police and Crime Commissioner? - (2012-10-27)
[3921] On rememberance, on war, and on preventing the war cycle - (2012-11-11)
[4079] Melksham Area - Unitary Council results, May 2013 - (2013-05-04)
[4223] Democracy - alive and well with the beauty pagent starting up again - (2013-12-16)
[4275] Eurpoean Elections, and other elections ahead. Some thoughts on campaigns and policies - (2014-05-08)
[4286] Reaction in Radstock to new First bus prices - (2014-07-12)
[4343] Politics and the railway the connects Wiltshire - (2014-12-06)
[4354] Wiltshire Police - assuming someone is guilty just on the say-so of a member of the public? - (2014-12-16)
[4476] Upcoming election - Chippenham Constituency - the major candidates compared - (2015-04-29)
[4485] Misusing statistics? - the seedy side of election campaigning - (2015-05-04)
[4489] Election results - what if we had a party list system? - (2015-05-08)
[4548] Melksham - two small townships, or one big one? - (2015-10-22)
[4597] Not standing as your local councillor - (2015-12-18)
[4614] PC Plod - alive and scaremongering in Wiltshire? - (2016-01-04)
[4625] Where does Wiltshire bus subsidy money come from? - (2016-01-19)
[4720] Celebrating our diversity rather than discriminating for it - (2016-11-02)
[4725] Writing Python 2 such that Python 3 is easy - (2016-11-06)
[4729] The oldest part of Los Angeles - (2016-11-23)
[4734] Thoughts on the new Blackmore Ward of Melksham Without Parish - (2017-02-22)
[4735] Revisiting - should I stand for Melksham Without Parish Council in May? - (2017-02-24)
Some other Articles
New bus times - Melksham to BathWhere do I find .... (Our hotel FAQ)The Accidental HotelierSigns of AutumnGood cause giving - getting the charity beggars off the streetRooms ready for guests - each time, every time, thanks to good system designCaching Design PatternsRelax at Well House Manor - gardens, fountain, hotelCopying, duplicating, cloning an object in PHPAutoload in PHP