As I tried to put together my final thoughts on Wiltshire's Strategic Plan Consultation, I helped myself by putting an overview of my thoughts together so that my inputs really will be strategic and not just about what we want / don't want in our back yard!
A Vision for Wilsthire ...
Where should Wiltshire be going in the next 20 years? What will your home town and your lifestyle be in (say) 2026, or the years leading up to it and thereafter? Is this a place that you'll be proud to live in, or have your children living in? Is it going to be somewhere that's a safe, happy, practical, and environmentally and economically sustainable for everyone?
Wiltshire Council is currently soliciting views under their ""Core Strategy"" consultation so that they can take those views into consideration as the formulate stategic plans leading up to 2026 and beyond. There are bold decisions to be made - and the question "where do we want to be in 2026?" needs to be asked and answered prior to the question "how do we get there?"
Wiltshire has been descibed as a "largely rural county" but at the current time, that applies only to the fact that most of the land is not built up, but rather is agricultural or open. The majority of the population lives in towns or the city of Salisbury rather than in villages, hamlets or isolated dwellings, and the majority of the working population and economic wealth is within those towns and cities rather than in the villages and countryside.
However, a disproportionate expense attaches to the village / isolated dwellings; it costs more to provided a bus service five miles to a village of 500 people than it does to server 500 people who live in the next streets in a town to where a bus serves another community, and furthermore the children in the village will need to be provided with transport to school, whereas as an extension of the town they'll simply be able to walk to school. So this urbanisation is not only efficient when it comes to cost, but also when it come to the time, efficiency, sustainability for the people involved.
Under the Regional Spatial Strategy that's already in place, considerable population growth is called for in Wiltshire, and we should be looking at growth of between 15% and 40% in the number of individuals in the County. On current trends (which look set to continue), average household size is reducing and where a typical home may have 2.6 people at present, it will have 2.3 in 20 years. The population is also aging, which means there is a need for a disproportionate growth in services for the elderly - health care, mobility, leisure activities, home support, etc.
Will we have the resources to see us through to 2026 and beyond (and should we be looking beyond)?
1. Even with the additional housing stock implied by the plans being built at low density on what is currently agricultural land, well under 2% of such land would be taken up. In practise, with grouped housing / higher density living in affordable homes, sheltered and cared accommodation, the figure will be considerably lower. However, not all agricultural land is suitable for development, with issues such as flooding, waterlogging, and access to be considered.
2. Fossil fuels and other materials are limited resources; at current rates of use, some resources are set to run out (it is said) within 20 years, whereas other resources will continue to be available into the distant future. Whilst further resources may be found / available / forthcoming, it is prudent to make efficient uses of what resources we have, and to use alternatives which are less limited or are replemished / sustained into the future.
3. The effect of human life on the wide environment is also under consideration - be it in the form of 'global warming', carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, effects on the strathosphere such as the ozone layer. These items may be much argued over - is it indeed the effect of human life and our way of living that's effecting the environment around us, or is it just natural cycles? But once again, it is prudent for us to reduce the effect we have on the wider environment around us - if we damage our environment, it may be permanent - but if we preserve it, the worst we'll be doing is taking some unneeded precuations.
4. Local waste is also an issue - the immediate fouling of the area that we live in, quite apart from the wider area. We're looking at rubbish, clogged roads, overrun services, and once again it does no harm to go forward with a less heavy footprint even though (in the benefit of hindsight) it might not turn out to have been necessary.
To make more use than is really needed of resources that may run out in the future, and in doing so to perhaps produce a negative global and local environmental is hypocritical. To cherish resources, using less resource rather than more, and using something that's more replemishable rather than less, is the only logical and caring way for us to go.
So what does putting this together mean for Wiltshire?
The growth necessary for to support the future population can come in several ways.
a) The extra growth could be allowed to happen ad-hoc, with commercial interests taking he lead and with infrastructure provision following.
b) A new town could be built, with the extra growth being placed there and existing towns continuing on with little change
c) Extra growth could be channelled into the existing towns
Ad-hoc development would lead to a sprawl of communities - a growth of villages and hamlets, of bottlenecks and no-go zones. There's no natural geography in Wiltshire (as perhaps there would be in a land of valleys such as the Norwegian Fjords) which would provide an external influence to channel ad-hoc growth in modern society whereas there was in the past - with towns developing in valley bottoms or at defendable positions.
A new town could be provided in Wiltshire - indeed "West of Swindon" is such a suggestion - but it will cost a great deal to provide complete and new infrastructure not only for a town, but for a substantial town with the facilites to be considered complete. And such a new town, with the corollary of ceasing most moves forward at other towns in the vicinity, could lead to those other towns moving into a slow decline.
Extra growth into existing towns will mean some growing pains, but also some huge opportunities; towns need to be looked at individually to see what suits them best. There are some towns which are currently of a natural size and with a natural character where substantial growth would detract from that balance and character which should be retained ... where current infrastructure is not easily extensible, and local opinion is in favour of the status quo. There are other towns for which growth would be a positive benefit, bringing them to a size where that can have a much more complete range of facilities, and where such growth is welcomed and encouraged from within the town.
There is a natural desire on the part of many people to ask for their own area to be left alone, and for development to carry on elsewhere, and if everyone succeeeded with this argument ("NIMBYism") then nothing would get done. But a town that's being left alone will typically going into a quiet decline, and it won't be that the status quo is maintained - it's likely that you'll see a slow degredation of services, and an increase in poverty.
Wiltshire Council's draft strategy
The council's draft strategy calls for substantial growth in Chippenham, Trowbridge, and in an are known as "West of Swindon". (Salisbury and South Wiltshire have their own plan and are outside the scope of the current consultation).
For the next level of town - ranging from Melksham (largest in the group) down to towns with populations of around 4000 to 5000, it calls for a lower level of growth - essentially looking at what the current setup will support, with an expectation that an increasing number of services will need to be accessed from "the big three". These towns are know as the "market towns" in the Wiltshire Council documents
For smaller towns / and villages, the plans are broadly for infill, with many places not mentioned in the plans because nothing will be added, and others mentioned because a pocket of land has been identified within the town / village where extra houses could be built.
New communities / development in halmets with minimal services / isolated homesteads and small clumps of houses are discouraged by the strategy.
The strategy has much to commend it, and congratulations are due to Wiltshire Council on many areas of the strategy. However, a more detailed looked and further comment needs to be made, and plans amended to take account, in a number of areas.
Areas of Concern
a) Has the correct division been made between the larger towns and the Market Towns? Have the aspirations of the local population been truely considered, and is it right to treat a town of 23,000 in the same [headline] way that you treat one of 4,000, rather than treating it similarly to a town of 28,000? Statements made by staff (and planning recommendations already made by them) from the spatial planning unit conflict with the view of local businesses and population.
b) The individual area plans each need considerable local review. Some appear to have been drawn up in haste (and to be fair, this IS a consultation excercise), with information shown on plans being directly contradicted by Wiltshire Council employees who were on hand at the exhibitions held around the area in November and early December.
c) There is concern that not enough opportunity is being taken to implement the sustainability issues as defined earlier in this document within the plans; although they are being spoken of, that's not followed through as much as it could be to the detail of planning for people to enjoy a high standard of living and services with a practical reduction on the use of resources (including their own time) and production of waste to have such a standard.
"County" -> Unitary Areas
"Towns" -> Towns and City of Salisbury
"Larger Towns" -> Towns that are proposed as major centres - currently Salisbury, Chippenham, Trowbridge and West-of-Swindon
"Market Towns" -> Towns with population of 4,000 to 25,000, proposed for more limited satellite growth
Having cleared my mind with some of those broad brush strokes and asking "where are we going and why?", I have come up with the following which are worthy of detailed review / possible input
1. Should Melksham be considered / treated as a larger town, or a market town?
2. Where should the planned growth in the Melksham area be placed / where should be ungrown?
3. What infrastructure changes should be made for Melksham
4. How does travel and transport work within, through, between and beyond Wiltshire's settlements?
5. Tourism, culture and leisure
(written 2009-12-20, updated 2009-12-21)
Associated topics are indexed as below, or enter http://melksh.am/nnnn for individual articlesZ402 - Melksham Chamber of Commerce and Industry 
A customer service company - (2006-05-11) 
Asda opening large new store in Melksham - (2007-06-08) 
Business speed networking - a place tonight! - (2007-06-28) 
Remembrance day - inside a church and inside the day - (2007-11-11) 
Wiltshire County Council - Budget Consultation - (2007-11-15) 
Shopping for Christmas and looking forward - (2007-12-17) 
Flooding by Asda-s proposed new supermarket - (2008-01-12) 
Comments on proposed Asda Superstore for Melksham - (2008-01-14) 
Changing a screen saver from a web page (PHP, Perl, OSX) - (2008-05-06) 
Summer! - (2008-05-15) 
Hotel room prices - Melksham, Wiltshire - (2008-08-11) 
All the pieces fall into place - hotel and courses - (2008-09-10) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce, or the FSB - (2008-11-12) 
Wiltshire Council says - part 1 - (2008-11-13) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce and Industry - (2008-11-17) 
Ruby, Perl, Linux, MySQL - some training notes - (2008-11-23) 
Lidl opens in Melksham - (2008-12-11) 
Looking forward, in Melksham, in 2009 - (2009-01-05) 
One Cheer for Local Democracy - Asda in Melksham - (2009-01-11) 
Confidence, Customer Service and Tourism in Melksham - (2009-02-15) 
Blue Ridge and Melksham Chambers of Commerce - (2009-03-21) 
Business Networking for Melksham - 23rd April - (2009-04-01) 
Make your business a DESTINATION business - (2009-04-05) 
You cannot please all of the people all of the time - (2009-05-14) 
Melksham Business Map - Chamber of Commerce, Tourist Information and Town Council - (2009-05-21) 
Melksham Traders - where do we go? - (2009-06-05) 
Important - the future of Melksham / Chamber of Commerce - (2009-06-28) 
Wiltshire Community Area Partnerships - (2009-07-15) 
pre-Inaugural briefing - Melksham Community Area Partnership - (2009-07-15) 
Melksham - no trains, no southbound buses through the town - (2009-08-08) 
Wiltshire Unitary News - Chamber of Commerce Intelligence - (2009-10-04) 
New Web Site for Melksham Chamber of Commerce - (2009-10-18) 
Melksham Town - asleep or awake? - (2009-10-21) 
Melksham Forum - (2009-11-01) 
Planning the future of Wiltshire - (2009-11-07) 
Community Area Partnership - inaugural AGM - (2009-11-20) 
The road show has been - where now? - (2009-11-27) 
Melksham Market - Tuesdays, 09:00 to 14:00 - (2009-12-01) 
Melksham - new Tuesday Market - (2009-12-09) 
Rock and hard place .. and the relaxing right one won - (2009-12-18) 
How well do you know Melksham - a quiz for Christmas - (2009-12-21) 
Forums for your Melksham and open source discussions - (2010-01-09) 
Melksham Area - your community view is sought - (2010-01-23) 
How is your tax pound spent? - (2010-02-18) 
Random thoughts on Melksham Town Planning and development - (2010-03-08) 
Car Parking in Melksham - (2010-03-18) 
How do our tactics help us meet the strategy, for the greater good? - (2010-04-16) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce - Presidents report to AGM - (2010-05-19) 
The history and future of Melksham Chamber of Commerce - (2010-05-25) 
Tell the Melksham Chamber or you only have yourself to blame - (2010-05-26) 
Melksham - a gem in Wiltshire - (2010-06-26) 
Lorry Parking in Melksham - (2010-06-29) 
Transport in Wessex - today and into the future - (2010-07-04) 
Cycling in Melksham, and looking forward - (2010-07-11) 
Moved - Melksham Lorry Park - (2010-07-15) 
Melksham Oak - photos of the new community school - (2010-07-22) 
Wiltshire Council ask how they can help businesses - (2010-07-27) 
Getting into and out of Wiltshire towns .. a.k.a. Car Parking? - (2010-08-23) 
Welcome to Countrywides new Melksham store - (2010-09-15) 
A Melksham news roundup - (2010-09-18) 
Travel, Transport and Tourism - A vision for Melksham, 2026 - (2010-10-03) 
A river in Melksham is not just for boaters. - (2010-10-11) 
Melksham - two many councils? - (2010-12-16) 
Trowbridge and Melksham to Chippenham - more roadworks, even slower journey over the winter - (2010-12-30) 
Opportunities for Melksham - new businesses in the town - (2011-01-01) 
Wiltshire Rail services - a golden opportunity - (2011-01-21) 
Keep your business customer-friendly! - (2011-02-09) 
On consultations, car parking, and Melksham town centre - (2011-02-17) 
What is the Melksham Chamber of Commerce? - (2011-02-18) 
What proportion of the British Workforce still works a Monday to Friday, 9 to 5, week? - (2011-03-01) 
Melksham Campus - what, why, questions, concerns and how you can input - (2011-03-04) 
Melksham Campus - any last minute inputs from Melksham businesses? - (2011-03-26) 
Vandalism and riot from the minority - the effect - (2011-03-28) 
Melksham - the way forward. 26th April, Well House Manor - (2011-04-13) 
Events - Spring and Early Summer 2011 in Melksham - (2011-04-17) 
Melksham Car Parking - current charges and limits - (2011-05-01) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce - grows to appoint new Press Officer. Welcome. Sam - (2011-05-02) 
Letter to The Editor - (2011-05-06) 
Presidents Report to Melksham Chamber of Commerce, 24.5.2011 - (2011-05-24) 
Melksham Community Radio launches - (2011-05-28) 
The Olympic Torch, and Melksham House - (2011-06-14) 
A lesson from the sporran market? - (2011-06-25) 
Summer Sunday Timetable - TransWilts Trains - (2011-06-30) 
Summer Sunday Train Service Starts - Swindon Chippenham and Melksham to Weymouth - (2011-07-03) 
Melksham Jelly - An Occasional Office for Home Workers - (2011-08-06) 
Are people who walk into Melksham being asked to subsidise parking? - (2011-08-09) 
Making best use of the new enthusiasm for Melksham - (2011-09-05) 
1 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 12? - (2011-09-07) 
What is on the Melksham Agenda? - (2011-09-09) 
Melksham to become a part of Trowbridge? - (2011-09-13) 
Currently pictured in Melksham - (2011-10-09) 
Havant - Shop Frontages. - (2011-10-12) 
Some thoughts in answer to some Melksham Campus questions - (2011-10-14) 
Upcoming events in and about Melksham - more dates for your diary - (2011-10-22) 
Looking forward - Chamber of Commerce has 2012 and beyond on the agenda - (2011-10-26) 
Melksham - Business to Business Speed Networking - build ahead for 2012 - (2011-10-26) 
Melksham - changing times, an opportunity for the future - (2011-11-23) 
Melksham, Month by month through 2011 - (2011-12-23) 
Melksham Civic Awards - report and pictures - (2012-01-29) 
Meeting Report - Tuesday 21st Feb - to Melksham Chamber of Commerce from Shadow Community Operations Board - (2012-02-27) 
Changing shops and organisations - Melksham, the last and next five years - (2012-03-21) 
Melksham Train Service - please support the TransWilts case for regular trains - (2012-03-25) 
Some advise for guest speakers at meetings - (2012-03-31) 
Melksham Business Newsreel - (2012-04-03) 
Wiltshire Business Support Service - (2012-04-11) 
Melksham government and business organisations - (2012-04-14) 
Events in Melksham - read all about them, and tell us about yours - (2012-04-15) 
Why do people use chains rather than independent traders? - (2012-04-18) 
An exciting Chamber of Commerce AGM - sound like an Oxymoron? - (2012-04-25) 
Encouraging business in Melksham and its neighbourhood - keep business local?? - (2012-04-27) 
Just 12 winners? Or 371 or more? Town Centres. - (2012-04-30) 
Ten more visitors to your premises every day? - (2012-05-14) 
Go green - business seminar in Melksham - (2012-05-21) 
Not everyone has a computer - 9 more ways to learn about the Melksham Campus - (2012-06-03) 
Public transport for international arrivals into Melksham - (2012-06-04) 
Melksham Visitors Map - Bus routes and train lines to and from the town - (2012-06-04) 
How well do you know Melksham? - (2012-06-17) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce - looking to our future shape. Pivotal meeting next Tuesday - (2012-06-19) 
Melksham Pride - the Chamber of Commerce, and the future - (2012-06-29) 
The Melksham News - July 2012 - Part 1, Campus and Chamber of Commerce - (2012-07-22) 
Making things happen - litter and ASB and lost dogs in Melksham - (2012-07-25) 
Bus times - Chippenham Station to Melksham, with London connections - (2012-08-25) 
The difficult interface between the business, council and voluntary sectors - (2012-09-19) 
Chamber of Commerce - looking forward in Melksham and in Wessex - (2012-10-04) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce - whence in 2013 and beyond? - (2012-10-12) 
Quiet little town? Advanced Technology Centre? - (2012-12-08) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce - join us in our future - (2013-01-21) 
Images of Melksham you havent seen before - (2013-02-13) 
Costa Coffee in Melksham - is it a good idea? - (2013-02-22) 
Report on the last year - Melksham Chamber of Commerce and Industry for Melksham Without Parish Council - (2013-03-11) 
Over a hundred welcoming businesses - Melksham Town Centre - (2013-03-17) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce - Report for AGM, 21st May 2013 - (2013-05-21) 
Questions from children about Melksham Campus - (2013-05-26) 
Tell me a bit about Melksham - (2013-08-10) 
Melksham Market - every Tuesday - (2013-09-03) 
Herman Miller coming to Melksham - the Chamber of Commerce is briefed - (2013-09-10) 
Future Swindon - Westbury train services. At current level into the future? - (2014-05-25) 
The Campus in Melksham - name, logo, and livery choice - (2015-01-18) 
Annual review of Melksham Matters for Chamber of Commerce AGM - (2016-05-15) 
Melksham Chamber of Commerce - my final Presidents report - (2017-05-10)
Some other Articles
Ten years ago, we moved to Melksham SpaThe great thing about snow ....Scraping content for your own page via PHPVision for WiltshireDay and night at ChristmasMy armpit was like a zebra crossingVAT ChangesChanging Images